The Real Truth About Negotiating with Clients: What 15 Years in Business Taught Me

Connect with us: SB Nation | Medium | Doodle or Die | Elephant Journal | Manifold Markets

Three weeks ago, I watched a seasoned business owner cave completely during a client negotiation that should have been straightforward. This bloke had been running his consultancy for eight years, yet he folded like a cheap tent the moment the client mentioned "budget constraints." Walked away with 40% less than his quoted rate and a scope that had somehow tripled. Made me realise that most people still think negotiation is about being the loudest voice in the room.

Here's what really gets me fired up: negotiation isn't warfare, and it's definitely not about manipulation. After 15 years helping businesses improve their communication skills, I've seen too many professionals approach client negotiations like they're buying a second-hand ute from someone dodgy. Wrong mindset entirely.

The Foundation Everyone Gets Wrong

The biggest mistake I see? People think negotiation starts when you sit down at the table. Absolute rubbish.

Real negotiation begins the moment you first speak with a potential client. Every email, every phone call, every interaction is setting the stage for what happens later. You're either building your position or undermining it. There's no neutral ground here.

I learned this lesson the hard way back in 2010 when I was working with a Sydney-based property development firm. Spent three months providing excellent service, going above and beyond, really proving our value. When contract renewal time came around, I figured I'd earned the right to increase our fees by 15%. Seemed reasonable.

The client's response? "We love working with you, but we need to cut costs across all suppliers."

That's when it hit me. I'd been so focused on delivering great work that I'd completely neglected to communicate our increasing value throughout the engagement. Classic mistake that cost me thousands.

Understanding the Real Game

Here's something most business books won't tell you: successful negotiation is 70% preparation and 30% execution. But here's the kicker - most people spend 90% of their time worrying about what to say in the room and barely any time understanding who they're dealing with.

You need to know your client's business better than they do sometimes. What are their pain points? Who are their competitors? What does success look like for them? This isn't stalking - it's professional preparation.

Take Telstra, for example. Love them or hate them, their negotiation teams always come prepared. They understand their own value proposition inside and out, and they're not afraid to walk away from deals that don't make sense. That's the kind of confidence you need to develop.

The Power of Strategic Positioning

Your negotiating position isn't just about your prices or terms. It's about how you position yourself in the client's mind. Are you a vendor who competes on price? Or are you a strategic partner who delivers outcomes?

This distinction matters more than you might think. Strategic partners negotiate from a position of mutual benefit. Vendors get beaten up on price every single time.

I remember working with a Melbourne accounting firm who were constantly competing on price against online services. They were miserable, margins were terrible, and they were working ridiculous hours just to break even. We spent six months repositioning them as business growth specialists rather than compliance processors.

The transformation was remarkable. Same services, different conversation. Instead of "Can you do our books for $200 less than the other guy?" it became "How can you help us achieve our growth targets?" Completely different negotiation dynamic.

The Uncomfortable Truth About Value

Here's where I'm going to say something that might ruffle some feathers: if you can't clearly articulate why you're worth what you're charging, you're not ready to negotiate with anyone.

Too many business owners approach negotiations hoping the client will somehow see their value without being explicitly told what it is. That's like expecting someone to buy a car without telling them it has an engine.

Your value proposition needs to be so clear that a 12-year-old could explain it back to you. And here's the controversial bit - sometimes you need to be prepared to lose clients who don't understand or appreciate that value.

I know this sounds scary, especially when cash flow is tight. But undervaluing yourself in negotiations sets a precedent that's almost impossible to break. You train clients to expect discounts, scope creep, and endless revisions. Not a sustainable business model.

The Art of Saying No (Properly)

The word "no" is your most powerful negotiation tool, but most people use it wrong. They either avoid it completely or use it like a sledgehammer.

Effective negotiation requires what I call "constructive resistance." You're not just rejecting their request - you're redirecting the conversation towards mutually beneficial alternatives.

Instead of: "No, we can't do that for less money." Try: "I understand budget is a concern. Let's look at what we can adjust in the scope to meet your budget while still delivering meaningful results."

This approach keeps the conversation moving forward while protecting your position. You're being helpful without being a pushover.

When Things Go Sideways

Even the best preparation won't save you from difficult clients who seem determined to make your life miserable. I've dealt with my share of these over the years.

The key is recognising when you're dealing with someone who negotiates in bad faith. Some warning signs:

• Constantly moving goalposts during discussions
• Bringing up new requirements after agreements are reached
• Using emotional manipulation or aggressive tactics
• Refusing to provide clear decision-making criteria

When you encounter these behaviours, your best strategy is often to politely disengage. Life's too short to work with clients who don't respect the negotiation process.

The Follow-Through Factor

Here's something nobody talks about: what happens after you reach an agreement is just as important as the negotiation itself.

The way you handle the post-negotiation phase sets the tone for your entire working relationship. Document everything clearly, follow through on commitments promptly, and address any ambiguities immediately.

I learned this lesson after a particularly complex negotiation with a Brisbane-based manufacturing client. We'd spent weeks hammering out details, finally reached an agreement everyone was happy with, then proceeded to interpret half the terms differently in practice. Created unnecessary tension that could have been avoided with better documentation.

Building Long-Term Relationships

The best client negotiations aren't really negotiations at all - they're collaborative planning sessions between partners who trust each other.

This level of relationship takes time to build, but it's worth the investment. When clients see you as genuinely invested in their success, price becomes less important and professional development training becomes more about capability building rather than cost cutting.

I've got clients now who don't even ask for quotes anymore. They tell me what they need, I tell them what it costs, and we move forward. That's the ultimate goal of any business relationship.

The Technology Factor

Can't ignore how technology has changed the negotiation landscape. Video calls have made it easier to read body language and build rapport, but they've also made it easier for clients to comparison shop without really understanding what they're comparing.

Email negotiations are particularly tricky. Easy to misinterpret tone, impossible to read non-verbal cues, and everything gets documented whether you want it to or not. I still prefer phone calls for sensitive discussions, but that's becoming less common these days.

What Actually Works in Practice

After all these years, here's what consistently works:

Preparation beats personality every time. Know your numbers, understand your client's business, and have clear alternatives ready if they can't meet your requirements.

Confidence is contagious. If you don't believe in your value, neither will they. This doesn't mean being arrogant - it means being professionally assured about what you bring to the table.

Timing matters more than tactics. The best negotiators know when to push and when to pause. Sometimes the most powerful thing you can do is suggest continuing the conversation after they've had time to consider your proposal.

Flexibility within boundaries. Be creative about how you structure deals, but don't compromise on your core requirements. You can adjust payment terms, delivery schedules, or scope, but don't sacrifice profitability for the sake of winning work.

The Real Success Metric

Here's my controversial opinion: the goal of negotiation isn't to win - it's to create sustainable business relationships that benefit everyone involved.

I know this sounds soft compared to the "crush your opponents" mentality you see in some business circles, but it's actually more profitable in the long run. Clients who feel like they've been treated fairly become your best source of referrals and repeat business.

The clients I've had the longest relationships with are the ones where our initial negotiations were collaborative rather than combative. We focused on finding solutions that worked for both parties instead of trying to extract maximum value from each other.

This approach has served me well through economic downturns, industry changes, and all the various challenges that come with running a business in Australia. When tough times hit, these clients stick with you because they know you're genuinely invested in their success.

Where Most People Still Struggle

Even with all this advice, I still see the same mistakes repeatedly:

People negotiate against themselves before the client even responds. They offer discounts that weren't requested, add extra services for free, or apologise for their prices before presenting them.

Others get so focused on winning individual negotiations that they damage long-term relationships. Short-sighted thinking that usually costs more than it saves.

And probably the most common issue: not knowing when to walk away. Every negotiation should have a clear point where you're prepared to say "this isn't a good fit" and mean it. Without that boundary, you're not negotiating - you're just accepting whatever terms they offer.

Moving Forward

The business landscape keeps evolving, and negotiation strategies need to evolve with it. Remote work has changed how we build relationships. Economic uncertainty has made budget conversations more complex. Younger decision-makers often have different communication preferences than their predecessors.

But the fundamentals remain the same: understand value, communicate clearly, respect the process, and focus on long-term relationships rather than short-term wins.

Whether you're dealing with difficult people in general business situations or specifically working through negotiation training for your team, the principles of mutual respect and clear communication apply across all professional interactions.

The clients worth having are the ones who appreciate good work and are willing to pay appropriately for it. Your job is to find them, serve them well, and build relationships that last.

Stop undervaluing yourself, start preparing properly, and remember that good negotiation is really just good communication with stakes attached.